Denver Firefighters Want To Negotiate Over Disciplinary Matrix

Denver Firefighters, IAFF Local 858, have filed suit seeking to block the unilateral implementation of a disciplinary matrix.

Local 858 was in court yesterday seeking a court order to force the city to negotiate the disciplinary matrix because it is a mandatory subject for collective bargaining. The city claims the matrix is a management prerogative outside the scope of collective bargaining because discipline is addressed in the city charter.

A ruling is expected later this month.

What is a disciplinary matrix? It is a set of guidelines specifying designated penalties for designated rule violations. The purpose of a matrix is in theory a valid one: ensure that similarly situated employees receive similar penalties for the same infraction.

We have all seen situations where firefighter A gets a reprimand and Firefighter B gets suspended for essentially the same conduct. In much the same way that sentencing guidelines help ensure that all criminal defendants receive the same treatment in court, disciplinary matrixes are intended to level the playing field in the workplace without regard to race, gender, friendship or political affiliation.

The problem is treating people the same is not the same as treating people fairly. Critics of disciplinary matrixes cite cases where treating two employees who are not similarly situated the same is not right. For example under many disciplinary matrixes, a brand new employee who is late for work would be treated the same as a thirty year veteran with a previously untarnished record.

Disciplinary matrixes have also been criticized as tying the hands of fire department leadership in cases where an employee has a known problem (substance abuse, anger management, etc.) in terms of forcing that employee to get the help he or she needs.

Some of the criticisms of disciplinary matrixes can be resolved up front by building in a degree of flexibility to address unique situations. However, there remains an inherent conflict between being consistent from individual to individual, and being fair to each individual based on that person’s situation.





About Curt Varone

Curt Varone has over 40 years of fire service experience and 30 as a practicing attorney licensed in both Rhode Island and Maine. His background includes 29 years as a career firefighter in Providence (retiring as a Deputy Assistant Chief), as well as volunteer and paid on call experience. He is the author of two books: Legal Considerations for Fire and Emergency Services, (2006, 2nd ed. 2011, 3rd ed. 2014) and Fire Officer's Legal Handbook (2007), and is a contributing editor for Firehouse Magazine writing the Fire Law column.

Check Also

Let’s Go Brandon T-Shirt Prompts Investigation in San Francisco Fire Department

A San Francisco firefighter is facing a disciplinary investigation following a social media photo of him wearing a “Let’s Go Brandon” shirt while apparently engaged in fire department activities. The photo was posted on Twitter, and the poster tagged Mayor London Breed, a city supervisor, and the fire department, asking the question “is this the new official uniform for the SFFD?"

Suit Alleges Lemon Law Violation Over Defective $1.4 Million Aerial Platform

An Illinois fire department has filed suit against Seagrave Fire Apparatus, LLC, alleging breach of contract, breach of warranty, and violation of the state’s “lemon law” due to problems with a new 105-foot Apollo aerial platform. The Lockport Township Fire Protection District filed suit today in US District Court for the Northern District of Illinois.