Retirement of DC Lieutenant Raises Question of Pension Following Dishonorable Service

Today’s burning question: Can a firefighter who is facing disciplinary action, avoid facing any punishment for his misconduct by quickly retiring before he can be terminated?

Answer: An employee can resign at any time and there is nothing an employer can do to stop a separation of service from occurring. However, the employee’s entitlement to a pension is another story. A pension can be conditioned on honorable service. The laws and/or the contractual provisions that create the right to the pension would need to be properly drafted to prohibit an employee who is under investigation from being awarded a pension.

For the second time in two years, these difficult questions are being asked in the District of Columbia. Both cases involve allegations of neglect of duty by a fire lieutenant amidst the tragic death of a civilian.

In the current case, Lt. Guy Valentine was accused of a delaying his response to the choking death of 18-month-old Martin Cuesta on March 18, 2015. Despite being three blocks from the scene, it took crews nearly 11 minutes to arrive on scene. Lt. Valentine reportedly retired over the holidays as he awaited a trial board on disciplinary charges.

The case is not unlike that of Lt. Kellene Davis — who was in charge of the D.C. ladder truck in January, 2014 whose crew failed to render assistance to a heart attack victim, Medric “Cecil” Mills Jr., across the street from the fire station. Facing a trial board, charged with six counts of neglect of duty, Lt. Davis escaped any punishment by retiring.

In the aftermath of Lt. Davis’ retirement, the D.C. Council passed the “Firefighter Retirement While Under Disciplinary Investigation Amendment Act of 2014.” While stopping short of prohibiting firefighters who are under investigation from retiring, it does allow the department to impose fines of up to $5000 against those found to have committed “serious misconduct.” Those charged with “serious misconduct” can be granted a “conditional retirement” pending the outcomes of the proceedings.

Here is a copy of the act: Firefighter Retirement While Under Disciplinary Investigation Amendment Act of 2014

About Curt Varone

Curt Varone has over 40 years of fire service experience and 30 as a practicing attorney licensed in both Rhode Island and Maine. His background includes 29 years as a career firefighter in Providence (retiring as a Deputy Assistant Chief), as well as volunteer and paid on call experience. He is the author of two books: Legal Considerations for Fire and Emergency Services, (2006, 2nd ed. 2011, 3rd ed. 2014) and Fire Officer's Legal Handbook (2007), and is a contributing editor for Firehouse Magazine writing the Fire Law column.

Check Also

Medics and FD Sued Over Photos of Shooting Victim

The sister of a man who was shot and killed during Black Lives Matter protests in Cicero, Illinois last summer, has filed suit against two Cicero Fire Department paramedics and a retired lieutenant for taking and sharing photos of his body. Adriana Cazares filed suit today naming Frank R. Rand, Justin Zheng, Gene Lazcano and the Town of Cicero as defendants.

Suit by FDNY Ops Chief Alleges Promotion Denial Violates First Amendment

An FDNY deputy assistant chief who claims he was passed over for promotion to assistant chief for refusing to renounce letters to the editor he wrote decades ago relative to merit based testing, has filed suit alleging the city violated his First Amendment rights. DAC Michael F. Gala, Jr. filed suit late last year naming the city and Fire Commissioner Daniel A. Nigro as defendants.