Burning Question on Different Rates Of Pay

Today’s burning question: Can a municipality change your pay rate depending on the job/situation? For example, we have some 40-hour per week employees who receive a larger hourly rate to compensate them for the fewer hours they work compared to shift employees of the same rank. When the 40-hour employees work an overtime shift they switch their pay to the lower 53-hour rate. However, when 53-hour employees work non-shift related work they are not converted to a 40-hour rate. Is this practice legal under the FLSA?

Answer: There is nothing in the Fair Labor Standards Act that prohibits an employer from playing employees different rates of pay when working in different jobs, or even working the same job at different times. The examples are numerous: Firefighters may make more when working in certain specialty units, or working certain shifts, than they make when working their normal shift. If Job A pays $20/hour and Job B pays $25/ hour, and folks who work in Job A can also work in Job B and vice versa, the FLSA will not stand in the way.

The FLSA just requires that the employees be paid minimum wage, and overtime compensation if they work more than the statutory maximum of hours. But the FLSA is only part of the equation.

The other part of the equation is whether state law, collective bargaining agreements, and/or civil service laws permit employees to be paid different rates of pay. For example, if a collective bargaining agreement says anyone who works in Job B full time must receive $25/hour regardless of where they work, then it is the CBA that mandates the employee be paid $25/hour whether working in Job A or B.

Having said all this, the FLSA will have an important impact on any overtime that employees who work at different rates of pay must be paid. That is really a different issue than the one you asked, but it all is connected. Overtime paid to an employee who works at two or more different rates of pay must be calculated in accordance with US Department of Labor regulations. Rather than explain that here, click here for more details on overtime for folks who work at different rates.

As if that were not complicated enough… your scenario gets even more complicated. Under the FLSA, most employees are entitled to overtime after 40 hours in a 7-day workweek. Employees engaged in fire protection activities who qualify for the 7k exemption have a separate set of requirements that impacts both maximum hours worked as well as the length of the work period. The 7k requirements are complicated and beyond the scope of this question. What is worth pointing out is that when a 40-hour employee works in a position that qualifies under 7k, the following issue arises: does the firefighter get overtime after 40 hours in a week, or does the applicable maximum hours in a work period for 7 k firefighters apply? The difference is enormous because overtime for a 7k firefighter ranges from 53 hours in 7 days up to 212 hours in 28 days.

This is admittedly a different question than the one you asked but it points out the complexity of the FLSA issues that arise out of your seemingly simple question.

So to summarize: if an employer is legally allowed to pay an employee different rates of pay under state law, collective bargaining agreement, or civil service regulations, then the FLSA will allow it. However, paying employees different rates of pay can make overtime compensation calculations quite complicated. It becomes even more complicated when the employees are firefighters who work in both 40 hour/7day positions and 7k positions.

About Curt Varone

Curt Varone has over 40 years of fire service experience and 30 as a practicing attorney licensed in both Rhode Island and Maine. His background includes 29 years as a career firefighter in Providence (retiring as a Deputy Assistant Chief), as well as volunteer and paid on call experience. He is the author of two books: Legal Considerations for Fire and Emergency Services, (2006, 2nd ed. 2011, 3rd ed. 2014) and Fire Officer's Legal Handbook (2007), and is a contributing editor for Firehouse Magazine writing the Fire Law column.

Check Also

Burning Question on Retention of Fire Reports

Today’s Burning Question: We were cleaning out some of our office storage cabinets and found we have paper copies of our incident reports that go back into the 70’s. How long do we need to legally keep these reports? Answer: Fire reports need to be maintained as long as state law mandates, and perhaps longer

Burning Question: Limiting Off-Duty Work Amid The Covid-19 Pandemic

Today’s Burning Question: Amid the pandemic we are facing my department has instituted new orders to prepare for the near future. Many of our firefighters serve at surrounding fire departments as part-time members. Can the department place restrictions on their off-duty work? Answer: In ordinary times, a fire department that seeks to limit the outside employment of off-duty members faces a number of hurtles.