Sick Leave and Hypocrisy

Today’s burning question: My fire department has a sick leave policy that states “Members of the Department on sick leave, when not hospitalized, are expected to remain at home, unless authorized by a physician for light duty.”  There are exceptions for medical care, prescriptions, etc. Violation of this provision is grounds for dismissal. Is this a legal and supportable policy?

Answer: Assuming the policy is properly implemented there is nothing inherently illegal with such a policy. By properly implemented I mean in a collective bargaining work environment it would have to be negotiated. In addition it cannot have been implemented in retaliation for any protected activities (ie. it could not have been adopted in retaliation for someone’s use of sick leave under the Americans with Disabilities Act or Family Medical Leave Act, or perhaps some other protected activity such as firefighters exercising their First Amendment Rights or concerted activity rights).

Such a policy must also be administered properly and fairly across the board or it could run afoul of the ADA, FMLA or even violate someone’s substantive due process rights. Nevertheless there is nothing inherently illegal in requiring someone who is claiming to be sick to comply with such a policy.

As for whether such a policy is “supportable”, I suppose it depends on who is paying for an employee to stay out of work. I worked with a firefighter who owned a side business. This firefighter regularly abused his fire department sick leave often boasting he “had a right” to use it whenever he wanted whether or not he was sick. Oddly enough he did not offer ANY SICK LEAVE to the employees of his side business (some of whom were struggling financially to raise families themselves). Either they came to work or they did not get paid. When I asked him about the hypocrisy his response was that if he offered them sick leave they would abuse it. I also know a union that uses non-union bartenders at its hall and does not offer them any sick leave… yet the same union members would be the first to cry foul if such a policy was implemented to restrict their use of sick leave.

About Curt Varone

Curt Varone has over 40 years of fire service experience and 30 as a practicing attorney licensed in both Rhode Island and Maine. His background includes 29 years as a career firefighter in Providence (retiring as a Deputy Assistant Chief), as well as volunteer and paid on call experience. He is the author of two books: Legal Considerations for Fire and Emergency Services, (2006, 2nd ed. 2011, 3rd ed. 2014) and Fire Officer's Legal Handbook (2007), and is a contributing editor for Firehouse Magazine writing the Fire Law column.
x

Check Also

Georgia Firefighters Caught Up In Tax Return Scam

An income tax return preparer in Georgia that catered to firefighters is being investigated for tax fraud, and now the state is reviewing the returns of 1,400 taxpayers, most of whom are firefighters. The Georgia Department of Revenue has confirmed it is reviewing 1,400 returns prepared by Kim Griffin’s Tax Time.

Long Beach Firefighter Will Not Be Charged For Punching Innocent Suspect

A Long Beach, California firefighter who punched an elderly man he believed had just murdered one of his colleagues, will not be facing criminal charges. However, he will likely find himself a defendant in a federal civil rights lawsuit brought by the man and his wife.