New Haven Releases Internal Discipline Analysis To Skeptical Firefighters

The City of New Haven, Connecticut has completed an internal review of its fire department discipline process and concluded that complaints from minority firefighters that they are disciplined more frequently and more harshly are not borne out by the facts. However, both union officials and minority firefighters have been quick to criticize the report.

The report was completed internally and issued by the Office of the Corporate Counsel. It comes nearly five months after allegations surfaced last June by the New Haven Firebirds that Assistant Chief Patrick Egan, who oversees the disciplinary process, had been harsher on African American and Latino firefighters than whites.

The report found no statistical disparities either in the frequency of discipline or the severity of punishments handout out. It applied the EEOC’s 80% rule to the data, concluding that the frequency of discipline for whites, blacks and Latinos are well  within the tolerances permitted by federal law. 

Union President James Kottage was quoted as saying “This isn’t an investigation… This is an analysis of numbers.” Kottage also expressed a concern with the methodology of the report.

Firebirds representative Darrell Brooks was quoted as saying “My immediate response is I’m not surprised…. with all due respect to (the city attorney), I don’t expect him to say ‘yeah we got a problem.’”

Kottage and Brooks agree on one thing: they would have preferred an independent investigation.

Here is a copy of the report. Review-of-Race-and-Discipline-in-the-New-Haven-Department-of-Fire-Services

More on the story

About Curt Varone

Curt Varone has over 40 years of fire service experience and 30 as a practicing attorney licensed in both Rhode Island and Maine. His background includes 29 years as a career firefighter in Providence (retiring as a Deputy Assistant Chief), as well as volunteer and paid on call experience. He is the author of two books: Legal Considerations for Fire and Emergency Services, (2006, 2nd ed. 2011, 3rd ed. 2014) and Fire Officer's Legal Handbook (2007), and is a contributing editor for Firehouse Magazine writing the Fire Law column.
  • Jacob Dickman

    If the complaint is frequency of discipline, how is an analysis of numbers inappropriate? Often times, numbers can be skewed based on the input of data (specific variables) but it seems to me that the variables here are discipline and firefighter race.Analysis of numbers is far more of an objective conclusion than interviews or anecdotal data that can be subjective. 

    • If the complaint is frequency of discipline, how is an analysis of numbers inappropriate?


      An excellent point.

  • Andrew

    Having lived in and around New Haven for years, I can say the Firebirds are probably correct. Much as FDNY is the bastion of the NYC Irish, the New Haven FD is pretty much controlled by the Italians. Blacks, Latinos, hell, anyone whose name didn't end in a vowel* was guaranteed a tough time with NHFD. The New Haven Iltalian crowd STILL refers to African-Americans as mulignans (eggplants). East Haven, the city next door, has had their PD under Federal scrutiny for years for their treatment of minorities.


    New Haven's idea of a "statistical analysis" is probably 1/3 of the complaints were about the five percent of the department that is black, 1/3 about the four percent  hispanics and 1/3 about the 90% Italians. (Obviously, the percentages are made up, but I bet they're close, from years of observation).

    And lest the vast majority of decent Italians jump on me, I am NOT saying all italians are like this, just the ones in the East Haven – New Haven – West Haven – North Haven power structure. They make Capone look good by comparison.


    *And people with names like Shapiro didn't even stand a chance of getting on the department.


Check Also

San Francisco Investigating On-Duty Drinking Incident

The San Francisco Fire Department is back in the headlines with another news report about on-duty personnel drinking. The department is investigating an incident that occurred last September at Station 11 where on-duty personnel were hosting a party for a member who was being transferred.

Podcast Episode 24: Pink Collar Theft In The Fire Service

In this episode, Curt discusses a little known problem, Pink Collar Theft, with Kelly Paxton. Kelly runs the web site and is helping to debunk the myths that many of us have about fire service embezzlement.