Maryland Cybercasualty BC Files First Amendment Suit

A Maryland battalion chief who was terminated earlier this year for posts he made on Facebook has filed suit claiming his punishment violated his First Amendment rights.

Howard County BC Kevin Buker was fired on March 6, 2013 over certain social media activities he engaged in during January and February, 2013. According to the complaint:

  • On Sunday, January 20, 2013, while working a twenty-four (24) hour shift as the Battalion Chief for the Second Battalion of the Howard County Department of Fire and Rescue Services, Mr. Buker “posted” a satirical comment concerning assault weapons legislation that was pending in several jurisdictions in the United States on his Facebook page. The post could only be viewed by Mr. Buker’s Facebook “friends,” i.e. those individuals selected or approved by Mr. Buker, not members of the general public. At the time of his posting, Mr. Buker had approximately four hundred fifty (450) “friends.” Specifically, Mr. Buker stated in his post, “My aide had an outstanding idea …. Let’s kill someone with a liberal … then maybe we can get them outlawed too! Think of the satisfaction of beating a liberal with another liberal … its almost poetic….”
  • Mr. Buker’s Facebook friends subsequently responded to his initial post.
  • One of Mr. Buker’s Facebook friends, Mark Grutzmacher, responded to the post stating, “But … was it an ‘[assault] liberal’? Gotta pick a fat one, those are the ‘high capacity’ ones. Oh pick a black one, those are more ‘scary.’ Sorry had to perfect on a [sic] cool idea!” 
  • The aforementioned response, when read in its proper context refers to provisions in assault weapons legislation pending at the time which categorizes weapons by their size, magazine capacity and/or color.
  • Mr. Buker “liked,” a way of acknowledging a post on the Facebook platform, Mr. Grutzmacher’s comment, and then sent the following reply comment: “Lmfao! Too cool, Mark Grutzmacher.”
  • Back and forth comments concerning assault weapons legislation continued for several hours. These comments were made by Mr. Buker’s other Facebook friends.
  • Assistant Chief Jerome, Mr. Buker’s supervisor, ordered Mr. Buker to remove his original Facebook post regarding assault weapons legislation on January 22, 2013.
  • Mr. Buker complied with Assistant Chief Jerome’s request on January 23, 2013.
  • Mr. Buker made the following post to his Facebook friends when he deleted his original post regarding assault weapons legislation:

To prevent future ‘butthurt’ and comply with a directive from my supervisor, a recent post (meant entirely in jest) has been deleted. So has the complaining party. If I offend you, feel free to delete me. Or converse with me. I’m not scared or ashamed of my opinions or political leaning, or religion. I’m happy to discuss any of them with you. If [you’re] not man enough to do so, let me know, so I can delete you. That is all. Semper Fi! Carry On.

  • Mr. Buker’s January 23, 2013, post generated further comments among his Facebook friends. In response to a Facebook friend’s comment that “[a]s long as it isn’t about the FD, shouldn’t you be able to express your opinions,” Mr. Buker posted the statement:

Unfortunately, not in the current political climate. Howard County, Maryland, and the Federal Government are all Liberal Democrat held at this point in time. Free speech only applies to the liberals, and then only if it After [sic] tis in line with the liberal socialist agenda. County Government recently published a Social media policy, which the Department then published it’s own. It is suitably vague enough that any post is likely to result in disciplinary action, to include this one. All it took was one liberal to complain … sad day. To lose First Amendment rights I fought to [ensure]. Unlike the WIDE majority of Government I serve.

  • The Howard County Department of Fire and Rescue Services thereafter moved Mr. Buker out of field operations on January 25, 2013, pending the results of an internal investigation.
  • On February 17, 2013, a volunteer firefighter with the Howard County Department of Fire and Rescue Services posted on the internet a picture of an elderly woman with her middle finger extended. Under the picture the volunteer firefighter posted the statement, “This page, yeah the one you’re looking at, it’s mine. I’ll post whatever the fuck I want.” Above the picture, the volunteer firefighter posted the statement, “for you Chief.”
  • Mr. Buker “liked” the volunteer firefighter’s February 17, 2013 posting.
  • The Howard County Department of Fire and Rescue Services thereafter completed its investigation into Mr. Buker’s Facebook postings. The County and Chief Goddard subsequently terminated Mr. Buker’s employment effective March 6, 2013.

Chief Buker filed suit in US District Court last month claiming that his postings were “protected speech under the First Amendment to the United States Constitution in that they constitute a public employee’s speech on a matter of public concern.”

He is seeking reinstatement, back pay, damages for “mental anguish and distress”, costs and attorneys fees.

Here is a copy of the complaint. Buker v Howard County Fire

About Curt Varone

Curt Varone has over 40 years of fire service experience and 30 as a practicing attorney licensed in both Rhode Island and Maine. His background includes 29 years as a career firefighter in Providence (retiring as a Deputy Assistant Chief), as well as volunteer and paid on call experience. He is the author of two books: Legal Considerations for Fire and Emergency Services, (2006, 2nd ed. 2011, 3rd ed. 2014) and Fire Officer's Legal Handbook (2007), and is a contributing editor for Firehouse Magazine writing the Fire Law column.
x

Check Also

Spokane Fire Confronts Hazing of Probies

The Spokane Fire Department is reviewing an investigative report into allegations of hazing and bullying of probationary employees at one of their fire stations. The investigation was conducted by the city’s Human Resource department who interviewed 30 members.

Fired FDNY Probie Sues Over Harassment By Colleagues

An FDNY probie who washed out during his first year, has filed suit alleging he was subjected to an assortment of outrageous conduct by his coworkers. Michael Tronia filed suit last Friday alleging discrimination under federal, state and local law; assault and battery; retaliation; and Constitutional violations.