San Jose Settles Sex Discrimination Suit

The city of San Jose has agreed to settle a sexual discrimination suit brought last year by two female fire captains who claimed they were wrongfully denied promotions.

Captains Debra Ward and Patricia Tapia filed the suit in state court alleging that despite their high scores (Ward came out 1st and Tapia number 8th on the objective portion of the process) the city promoted nine men to battalion chief. The women were graded down during the subjective interview phase.

According to the suit, a number of the males who were selected were close friends of the fire chief and belonged to a Christian firefighter group led by a deputy chief. In addition, they alleged that after they were turned down for the promotion they were asked to train one of the men who was promoted.

The case has been settled for $395,000. Tapia, who also alleged race discrimination based on her Latino heritage, has already been promoted to Battalion Chief.

The settlement is the second sex discrimination suit settled by the city in recent years. Recall in 2009, the city settled with firefighter Julie LaBlanc, whose son came out of a fire station bathroom with a pornographic magazine in hand following a visit. When LeBlanc complained she was harassed by co-workers. Leblanc received a $200,000 settlement.

LeBlanc’s attorney, Angela Alioto, also represented Ward and Tapia. The settlement is expected to be approved by the city council on June 19, 2012.

More on the story.

About Curt Varone

Curt Varone has over 40 years of fire service experience and 30 as a practicing attorney licensed in both Rhode Island and Maine. His background includes 29 years as a career firefighter in Providence (retiring as a Deputy Assistant Chief), as well as volunteer and paid on call experience. He is the author of two books: Legal Considerations for Fire and Emergency Services, (2006, 2nd ed. 2011, 3rd ed. 2014) and Fire Officer's Legal Handbook (2007), and is a contributing editor for Firehouse Magazine writing the Fire Law column.
  • ukfbbuff

    The cost of STUPIDITY!

    $595,000 dollars literally flushed down the toilet by the Fire Chief William McDonald over gender harassment-bias litigation settlements.

    The City has financial problems and there goes that money that could have been better spent.

    It’s Not his money to play with, but that of the Citizens.

    This is what happens when Religion gets involved in the ” Chief’s ‘super secret’ qualifications list”. The bias is against the Women candidate.

    So, what happens next? Is William McDonald penalized (demoted, if the Mayor has the fortitude to do it)or does he become the next iChief’s “Chief of the year” as happened with the former Chief of Fresno, Ca., as the city was settling a $2 Million Dollar gender discrimination case there?

  • Pingback: Jury Awards San Jose BC $800k For Retaliation - Fire Law Blog()

x

Check Also

Supreme Court Refuses to Hear Howard County Social Media Appeal

The US Supreme Court has denied the request of Howard County Battalion Chief Kevin Buker to consider an appeal of his termination in 2013. Chief Buker was fired following a series of Facebook posts that began over the gun-control debate

Delaware Fire Company Sued For Third Time By Same Member

A volunteer fire company in Delaware is being sued for the third time by a female member who now claims she has been retaliated against on account of her previous suits. Wendy Lowe is suing the Laurel Volunteer Fire Department, Inc. alleging breach of contract, due process, defamation, and civil conspiracy